Hearthsea

Catan robber rules: the 7, discarding half and stealing

When a 7 is rolled, no hex produces. Every player holding more than 7 resource cards discards half of them, rounded down, so 9 cards means discarding 4. The player who rolled must then move the robber to a different hex and steal one random resource card from a player with a settlement or city on it. That hex produces nothing while the robber stays.

A painting of a hex island board game: a dark hooded wooden robber figure stands on a golden wheat hex numbered 8, two ivory dice lie in front, and a hand lays half of a fan of resource cards face down.
A 7, and half a hand on the table.

What happens when you roll a 7

A 7 is the most likely roll with two dice, 6 chances in 36, so it comes up about once every six rolls. It always runs in the same order:

  1. Nothing is produced. No hex has a 7, so nobody collects resources.
  2. Big hands discard. Every player with more than 7 resource cards discards half of them, rounded down. This includes the player who rolled.
  3. The robber moves. The player who rolled must move the robber to a different hex.
  4. One card is stolen. The roller takes one random resource card from one player with a settlement or city on that hex.

After that the turn goes on as normal: trading and building.

The 7-card rule: who discards, and round up or down?

Only players with more than 7 resource cards discard, so 7 cards is safe and 8 is not. Development cards don’t count. You discard half, rounded down, and you choose which cards go back to the supply. The official rulebook’s own example: 9 cards, discard 4.

How many cards to discard on a 7
Cards in hand7 or fewer8910111213
Discard0445566

Playing a Knight card moves the robber too, but it never makes anyone discard. The publisher’s FAQ is clear on that: only a rolled 7 does.

Where can the robber go?

The robber must move to a different land hex every time; you can’t leave it where it is. The desert is allowed. Most players aim for the hex that hurts the leader most: a 6 or an 8 with their city on it.

While the robber sits on a hex, that hex produces nothing for anyone when its number is rolled. Other hexes with the same number still produce. The robber does not stop anyone from building next to its hex.

Stealing: who you can take from

  • You may steal from one player who has a settlement or city on any corner of the robber’s new hex. If several players are there, you choose which.
  • The card is taken at random, face down. You don’t get to pick the resource.
  • If that player has no cards, you get nothing. Moving next to an empty hand is legal, it just steals nothing.
  • A hex with only your own buildings, or none at all, steals nothing either.

The Knight card and the robber

A Knight development card lets you move the robber and steal, exactly as on a 7 but without the discard. You can play it before you roll, which is how players chase the robber off their own best hex before it costs them another turn. Like every development card, you can play only one per turn, and not on the turn you bought it.

The first player to have played three Knights takes the Largest Army card, worth 2 points. Our development cards guide covers the rest of the deck.

The friendly robber and other house rules

The most common house rule is the friendly robber: the robber can’t be placed next to a player with 2 points or fewer, so a slow start isn’t punished twice. Some tables also raise the discard limit to 9 cards, or turn the robber off for younger players.

Hearthsea has all three as table settings: Friendly robber (no robbing a player with 2 visible points or fewer), the discard limit, and the robber itself. There are more ideas in our house rules post.

Common robber mistakes

  • Rounding up. 9 cards means discarding 4, not 5.
  • Counting development cards. Only resource cards count toward the 7.
  • Leaving the robber in place. It has to move to a different hex.
  • Discarding on a Knight. Only a rolled 7 makes anyone discard.
  • Choosing the stolen card. It’s taken at random.

The rules mistakes post has more of the ones that change who wins.

Questions people ask

What happens when you roll a 7 in Catan?

Nobody collects resources. Every player with more than 7 resource cards discards half, rounded down. The roller moves the robber to a different hex and steals one random card from a player with a building on it.

Do you round up or down when discarding in Catan?

Down. A player with 9 cards discards 4, and a player with 11 discards 5.

Can you put the robber on the desert in Catan?

Yes. The robber must move to a different hex, and the desert is a legal choice.

Does a Knight card make players discard?

No. Only a rolled 7 makes players with more than 7 cards discard. A Knight only moves the robber and steals a card.

Can you play a Knight before rolling?

Yes. A Knight can be played at any time during your turn, including before you roll the dice.

What is the friendly robber rule?

A house rule that stops the robber from being placed next to a player with 2 points or fewer. Hearthsea has it as a table setting.

Sources

Read on 3 November 2026:

  1. CATAN – The Game: 6th edition rulebook (PDF)
  2. CATAN: base game FAQ

Keep reading

Practise the 7, free

Hearthsea is free to play: Classic and Seafarers on all 51 islands, against bots or online with friends, with no daily limit. Highlands, Skyfarers, The Spice Road and Cities & Knights are optional at $4.99 a month each, or $9.99 a month for all four, and every account plays one free game of each a day. The free lessons walk you through a 7, the discard and the robber step by step.

Play free

CATAN is a registered trademark of Catan GmbH. Hearthsea is an independent game and is not affiliated with, endorsed by or sponsored by Catan GmbH or its publishers. Other game names belong to their owners and are used here only to describe and compare.