Hearthsea

Catan numbers: pips, odds and why 6 and 8 are red

The dots under a Catan number, called pips, count the ways two dice can roll it out of 36. A 6 or an 8 has 5 pips, so each comes up about once every 7 rolls; that is why they are printed in red. The deck has 25 development cards, 14 of them knights, and each player has 5 settlements, 4 cities and 15 roads.

A painting of a red 6 and a red 8 number token with five dots each on a hex island board, two ivory dice beside them and a parchment sheet with a bell-shaped bar chart.
Five dots on the 6 and the 8: five ways to roll each, out of 36.

What the dots under the numbers mean

Count the dots. That one habit fixes most bad opening placements, and it takes a second per number.

Two dice give 36 equally likely results. A number’s dots, or pips, tell you how many of those 36 roll it: one dot for the 2 and the 12, five for the 6 and the 8. Add up the pips of the three hexes around a corner and you have that corner’s expected output. A corner on 6, 5 and 9 has 13 pips; a corner on 2, 3 and 11 has 5.

Chance of each total with two dice Out of 36 equally likely results: 2 and 12 come up 1 way each, 3 and 11 two, 4 and 10 three, 5 and 9 four, 6 and 8 five, and 7 six ways. 1/3622/3633/3644/3655/3666/3675/3684/3693/36102/36111/3612
Ways to roll each total, out of 36. The red 6 and 8 are the best numbers you can build on; 7 rolls most and produces nothing.

The odds of every number

Chance of each total with two dice, and how often it comes up
NumberPipsChance per rollAbout once every
212.8%36.0 rolls
325.6%18.0 rolls
438.3%12.0 rolls
5411.1%9.0 rolls
6513.9%7.2 rolls
7616.7%6 rolls (the robber)
8513.9%7.2 rolls
9411.1%9.0 rolls
1038.3%12.0 rolls
1125.6%18.0 rolls
1212.8%36.0 rolls

A 4-player game of Catan runs about 70 rolls. Over 70 rolls a 6 is expected about 10 times and a 2 about twice, which is why a settlement on two 6s and an 8 feels rich by the tenth turn.

Why are 6 and 8 red in Catan?

6 and 8 are red because they are the most likely numbers that still produce. Only 7 rolls more often, and 7 produces nothing: it moves the robber. The rules use the red too. The 5th edition rulebook says that if you lay the number tokens out at random, “the tokens with the red numbers must not be next to each other,” and you swap tokens until they aren’t. Hearthsea’s board generator deals its Fair boards the same way.

Red numbers also attract the robber. A hex on 6 or 8 is where the robber does the most damage, so a start built only on red numbers loses a lot when the robber lands there.

How many of each card and piece are in the box

What the base game box holds (3–4 players)
ItemHow manyNotes
Resource cards9519 each of lumber, brick, wool, grain and ore
Development cards2514 knights, 5 victory points, 2 road building, 2 year of plenty (called Invention in the 6th edition), 2 monopoly
Terrain hexes194 forest, 4 pasture, 4 fields, 3 hills, 3 mountains, 1 desert
Number tokens18one 2 and one 12; two each of 3 to 11, no 7
Harbors9four 3:1 and one 2:1 for each resource
Pieces per player245 settlements, 4 cities, 15 roads
Points to win10settlement 1, city 2, Longest Route (Longest Road before the 6th edition) 2, Largest Army 2, victory point card 1

The 5–6 player extension adds hexes, tokens and cards: the larger box’s deck has 20 knights, and the bank holds 24 of each resource. On Hearthsea the bank never runs out, so a resource can’t dry up mid-game the way it can with the box.

Your chances when you buy development cards

With 14 knights in 25 cards, each card you draw from a fresh deck is a knight 56% of the time and a victory point 20% of the time. Largest Army needs 3 knights played, and on average that takes about 5 cards:

Chance after buying several development cards from a full deck
Cards boughtAt least 3 knightsAt least 1 victory point
316%50%
440%62%
562%71%
679%78%
790%84%
896%88%

Our development cards guide covers when to play each one.

Using the numbers at your next game

  • Count pips, not hexes. Three hexes on 2, 12 and 3 are worth less than one hex on 6.
  • Spread your numbers. Two settlements that share no numbers produce on more rolls, so you wait less between cards.
  • Don’t sit only on red. The robber goes where the pips are.
  • Total around 20 pips for your two starting settlements on a normal board. Our 10,000-game study found the most pips don’t always win, but very few pips rarely do.

Count the pips on a fair board
A free account opens this exact board against three bots.

Questions people ask

What do the dots mean on Catan numbers?

The dots, called pips, count how many of the 36 two-dice results roll that number. A 6 or 8 has 5 dots, a 2 or 12 has 1. More dots means the hex produces more often.

Why are 6 and 8 red in Catan?

They are the most likely numbers after 7, rolling 5 times in 36 each. Since 7 produces nothing, 6 and 8 are the best numbers on the board, and the 5th edition rules say two red numbers must not sit next to each other on a random board.

How many knights are in a Catan deck?

The base game deck has 14 knights in 25 development cards. The 5–6 player extension deck has 20 knights.

How many development cards are in Catan?

25: 14 knights, 5 victory point cards, 2 road building, 2 year of plenty (Invention in the 6th edition) and 2 monopoly.

How many resource cards are in Catan?

95, which is 19 of each of the five resources.

How many points do you need to win Catan?

10 victory points, in the base game with 3 or 4 players and in the 5–6 player extension.

How many settlements, cities and roads does each player get?

Each player has 5 settlements, 4 cities and 15 roads.

Sources

Read on 15 November 2026:

  1. CATAN – The Game: 6th edition rulebook (PDF)
  2. CATAN: base game rules and almanac, 5th edition (PDF)
  3. CATAN: base game FAQ

Keep reading

Play a fair board now

Hearthsea is free to play: Classic and Seafarers on every island, against bots or online with friends, with no daily limit. Highlands, Skyfarers, The Spice Road and Cities & Knights cost $4.99 a month each, or $9.99 a month for all four, and every account gets one free game of each a day. This button opens a board the board generator dealt fair, with no red numbers touching.

Play this board free

CATAN is a registered trademark of Catan GmbH. Hearthsea is an independent game and is not affiliated with, endorsed by or sponsored by Catan GmbH or its publishers. Other game names belong to their owners and are used here only to describe and compare.