Hearthsea

The friendly robber in Catan: the official rule

The friendly robber is a Catan variant that protects players with only 2 victory points. The robber can’t be moved to a hex next to them, and nobody can steal from them, whether a 7 was rolled or a knight played. If no hex is allowed, the robber goes to the desert. It is official, but it comes from the Traders & Barbarians expansion, not the base game.

A painting of a small dark hooded robber figure on a hex island board turning away from a village of two small houses with a raised hand, and striding toward a big walled city on a wheat field, players smiling behind.
Two points and you’re safe: the robber heads for the city instead.

The official friendly robber rule

It’s in the Traders & Barbarians box, as a variant you can add to any game of Catan.

The 5th edition text reads: “When a ‘7’ is rolled or a knight card is played, the robber may not be moved to a terrain hex that is adjacent to a settlement of a player who only has 2 victory points. If, because of this rule, the robber has no valid terrain hex to move to, the robber moves to (or remains on) the desert hex. In this case, a resource card may not be taken from any player who only has 2 victory points.”

The 6th edition (2025) shortens it: “You may not move the robber to a hex with the building of a player who only has 2 VPs. If there is no valid hex, move the robber to the desert. In this case, steal 1 random card from a player with an adjacent building as long as they have more than 2 VPs.” Saying “building” instead of “settlement” means a city counts too.

The story behind it, from the 5th edition: the old robber has retired, and his replacement, “Rob de Hood”, supposedly takes only from rich travelers.

What the friendly robber changes, and what it doesn’t

The friendly robber at a glance
SituationWith the friendly robber
A 7 is rolledThe robber can’t go on a hex next to a 2-point player.
A knight is playedSame restriction. The rule covers knights, not only 7s.
Every hex touches a 2-point playerThe robber goes to the desert. You may steal there only from a player above 2 points.
You hold more than 7 cards on a 7You still discard half. Protection doesn’t cover the discard.
A player reaches 3 pointsFrom then on the robber can target them like anyone else.

In a normal game everyone starts with 2 points, so the rule really protects players who haven’t built anything since setup: the slow starter, the new player, the child at a family table. The Traders & Barbarians rules say the variant “should always be used when playing with family members, particularly when children are participating in the game.”

Where the friendly robber is official

The friendly robber across Catan products and apps
WhereFriendly robber?
Catan base game, 5th and 6th editionsNot in the rules
Traders & Barbarians, 5th and 6th editionsYes, as a variant
Catan for Two (in Traders & Barbarians)No. It has its own way of sending the robber to the desert.
SeafarersCan be added, says Traders & Barbarians
Cities & KnightsNot listed as compatible. The robber waits in the desert until the first barbarian attack instead.
ColonistA room setting, on by default in ranked 1v1
Catan UniverseA custom-game option, per a 2017 developer reply (not rechecked)
HearthseaA table setting, off by default

The Traders & Barbarians text says the variant combines with “all other T&B variants, T&B scenarios, and Seafarers scenarios, without rule changes.”

Three questions the rule doesn’t answer

Do hidden victory point cards count? The rulebook doesn’t say. Colonist counts only points everyone can see, so a player holding a secret victory card stays protected. Hearthsea does the same.

What if you drop back to 2 points? The rule reads as a live check, so if you lose Longest Road and fall back to 2, you’re protected again. The rulebook doesn’t spell this out.

What about Cities & Knights, where you start with 3 points? No official version exists. Tables that want one usually raise the line to 3 points. That is a house rule.

The versions people actually play

Ask five Catan groups how the friendly robber works and you’ll hear five rules. Agree on one before the first roll:

  • The official one: no hex touching a 2-point player.
  • Until anyone reaches 3: the robber stays in the desert until the first player passes 2 points.
  • Until everyone reaches 3: stricter, and much slower to switch off.
  • Block but don’t steal: the robber may sit on a shared hex, but you can’t steal from the 2-point player.
  • No 7s in the first rounds: some tables reroll 7s for the first two rounds instead.

More table rules worth trying are in our house rules guide.

Does the friendly robber change who wins?

Barely. We ran 5,000 four-player games between Hearthsea’s Veteran bots with the official rule switched on, and 5,000 without, each on a fresh fair board.

5,000 four-player games with and without the friendly robber (Veteran bots, 18 October 2026)
Normal robberFriendly robber
Rounds to a winner (average)17.4717.2
First player’s win rate (fair share 25%)27.8%27.8%
Games won by someone not leading at round 1235.0%35.8%
Losers’ points at the end6.496.57
Sevens rolled per game11.3511.18

The first player won just as often, and games ran a fraction of a round shorter. The rule shapes how the opening feels more than who wins: nobody gets robbed before they’ve built anything. That is the point of it at a family table, and the reason Colonist uses it for 1v1, where one early steal can decide a game.

Turning it on in Hearthsea

On Hearthsea the friendly robber is a switch in a table’s rules. With it on, the robber leaves alone anyone showing 2 points or fewer, for 7s and knights alike. Hidden victory point cards don’t count, and if every hex is protected, the robber goes to the desert. The room shows the setting to everyone before the game starts.

Play a fair board free
A free account opens this board against three bots.

Questions people ask

What is the friendly robber in Catan?

A variant that protects players with only 2 victory points. The robber can’t be placed next to them, and nobody can steal from them, until they reach 3 points.

Is the friendly robber an official rule?

Yes, as a variant in the Traders & Barbarians expansion, in both the 5th and 6th editions. It isn’t part of the base game rules.

Does the friendly robber apply to knight cards?

Yes. The official rule covers both a rolled 7 and a played knight. A knight can’t send the robber next to a 2-point player either.

Where does the robber go if every hex is protected?

To the desert. You may then steal only from a player next to the desert who has more than 2 points.

Do you still discard on a 7 with the friendly robber?

Yes. Players with more than 7 cards still lose half. The friendly robber only limits where the robber goes and who can be robbed.

Do victory point cards count for the friendly robber?

The rulebook doesn’t say. Colonist and Hearthsea count only visible points, so a hidden victory card doesn’t end your protection.

What is friendly robber on Colonist?

A room setting that protects players until they openly have more than 2 points. It is on by default in Colonist’s ranked 1v1, which plays to 15 points.

Does Catan Universe have the friendly robber?

A developer said in 2017 that it is available in custom games only. We haven’t rechecked the current app.

Does the friendly robber work with Cities and Knights?

It isn’t an official combination. Cities & Knights starts you on 3 points and keeps the robber in the desert until the first barbarian attack.

Is the friendly robber good for beginners?

Yes. The Traders & Barbarians rulebook recommends it for family games, especially with children, so nobody loses cards before they’ve built anything.

Sources

Read on 19 November 2026 (rule text quoted from both Traders & Barbarians rulebooks):

  1. CATAN: Traders & Barbarians rules, 5th edition (PDF)
  2. CATAN: Traders & Barbarians rulebook, 6th edition (publisher PDF)
  3. CATAN: base game FAQ
  4. CATAN: Cities & Knights rules, 5th edition (PDF)
  5. Colonist: ranked 1v1 strategy guide (friendly robber and 15 points)
  6. Catan Universe on Steam: developer reply on the friendly robber (2017)
  7. Hearthsea: we simulated 10,000 games of Catan (method and data)

Keep reading

A gentler robber, if you want one

Hearthsea is free to play: Classic and Seafarers on every island, against bots or online with friends, with no daily limit. Highlands, Skyfarers, The Spice Road and Cities & Knights cost $4.99 a month each, or $9.99 a month for all four, and every account gets one free game of each a day. Hosts can switch the friendly robber on for any table.

Play this board free

CATAN is a registered trademark of Catan GmbH. Hearthsea is an independent game and is not affiliated with, endorsed by or sponsored by Catan GmbH or its publishers. Other game names belong to their owners and are used here only to describe and compare.