Hearthsea

Largest Army in Catan: rules, points and ties

Largest Army goes to the first player with 3 knight cards played face up, and it is worth 2 victory points. It moves only when another player has played more knights than the holder, so in a tie the holder keeps it. Only played knights count. The base deck has 14 knights among its 25 development cards, and the 5–6 player deck has 20.

A painting of three development cards with armoured knights on horseback fanned beside a card of crossed swords over a shield, small carved knights with banners on a hex island board, a goblet and dice by candlelight.
Three knights played: the first army big enough to claim the card.

The Largest Army rule

Largest Army is a 2-point bonus for the player who has played the most knights, with a minimum of three.

The 6th edition (2025) puts it in three sentences: “The first player to have 3 Knight cards in play receives this tile. If another player has more Knight cards in play, they immediately receive this tile. The Largest Army tile is worth 2 VPs.” The 5th edition says the same, calling it a special card rather than a tile.

  • Played knights only. The catan.com FAQ compares an unplayed knight to a lottery ticket you never handed in. Knights in your hand don’t count.
  • It counts all game. Largest Army is your running total of knights played, not knights in one turn.
  • It moves at once. The moment a rival’s total passes yours, the card and its 2 points go to them, even mid-turn.

What happens in a tie

The holder keeps it. Neither rulebook uses the word “tie”. The card moves only to a player with more knights than the holder, so drawing level isn’t enough. If you have 3 knights out and a rival plays their third, you keep Largest Army; they need a fourth.

Longest Road works differently, which is why people get confused. It has a written tie rule: if the holder’s road is broken and two players tie for longest, the card is set aside until one of them pulls ahead. Largest Army needs no such rule, because played knights are never taken away in the base game.

When you can play a knight

A knight is a development card, so the development card rules apply:

  • One card per turn. You can’t play two knights in a turn, or a knight and a monopoly.
  • Not the turn you bought it. A knight bought this turn waits until your next one. Only victory point cards are exempt.
  • Before or after rolling. You may play a knight before you roll, to move the robber off your best hex first.
  • No discards. The FAQ is clear: playing a knight doesn’t make anyone discard. Only a rolled 7 does.

So you can take Largest Army and win on the same turn, as long as the third knight was bought on an earlier turn.

How many knights are in each deck

Knight cards in the development deck
GameKnightsDeck size
Catan base game (5th and 6th editions)1425
With the 5–6 player extension2034
Seafarers14 (uses the base deck)25
Cities & KnightsNone: the deck and Largest Army are set aside—
Explorers & PiratesNone: no development cards, no Largest Army—

Cities & Knights replaces both with its own knight pieces and the barbarian track. Our Cities & Knights rules explain what takes their place.

How many cards to buy for three knights

With 14 knights in a 25-card deck, each card drawn from a fresh deck is a knight 56% of the time. The exact chance of holding at least three knights after a number of buys:

Chance of at least 3 knights after buying N development cards from a full deck
Cards boughtBase deck (14 of 25)5–6 player deck (20 of 34)
316%19%
440%45%
562%67%
679%83%
790%92%
896%96%

On average it takes five cards, which is five ore, five wool and five grain. That is why Largest Army tends to follow an ore-and-grain start, and why the knights you play along the way matter: each one also moves the robber and steals a card. The full deck odds are in our Catan numbers guide.

Can you lose Largest Army?

Only to a player who plays more knights than you. Nobody can steal it, trade for it or destroy your knights in the base game. The one official way to lose played knights is in Catan for Two, the two-player variant in Traders & Barbarians, where you may discard a face-up knight for trade tokens. The 6th edition warns: “It is possible to lose control of the Largest Army tile this way.”

Hearthsea plays the base rule: three knights to claim it, and a rival must play more than the holder to take it.

Race for Largest Army
A free account opens this board against three bots that buy knights too.

Questions people ask

How many knights do you need for Largest Army?

Three played knights to claim it first. After that, a rival needs more played knights than the current holder to take it.

How many points is Largest Army worth?

2 victory points, the same as Longest Road. The points go with the card when it changes hands.

What happens in a Largest Army tie?

The holder keeps it. The card moves only to a player with more knights played, so drawing level isn’t enough to take it.

Can Largest Army be stolen or traded?

No. It can’t be stolen, traded or given away. It moves only when another player has played more knights than the holder.

How many knights are in a Catan deck?

14 in the base game’s 25 development cards. The 5–6 player extension adds 6 more, for 20 knights in 34 cards.

Do unplayed knights count toward Largest Army?

No. Only knights played face up in front of you count. Knights in your hand don’t.

Can you play a knight the turn you buy it?

No. A development card bought this turn can’t be played until your next turn. Only victory point cards are an exception.

Can you play two knights in one turn?

No. You may play one development card per turn, whatever kind it is.

Can you play a knight before rolling?

Yes. You may play a knight before you roll the dice, for example to move the robber off your own hex first.

Does playing a knight make players discard?

No. The catan.com FAQ says discarding happens only when a 7 is rolled. A knight moves the robber and steals one card.

Is Largest Army in Cities and Knights?

No. Cities & Knights sets aside the development deck and the Largest Army card and uses knight pieces instead.

Sources

Read on 19 November 2026 (rule text quoted from both editions and the catan.com FAQ):

  1. CATAN – The Game: 6th edition rulebook (PDF)
  2. CATAN: base game rules and almanac, 5th edition (PDF)
  3. CATAN: base game FAQ
  4. CATAN 5–6 player extension: 6th edition rulebook (PDF)
  5. CATAN: Cities & Knights rules, 5th edition (PDF)
  6. CATAN: Traders & Barbarians rulebook, 6th edition (publisher PDF)

Keep reading

Build your army

Hearthsea is free to play: Classic and Seafarers on every island, against bots or online with friends, with no daily limit. Highlands, Skyfarers, The Spice Road and Cities & Knights cost $4.99 a month each, or $9.99 a month for all four, and every account gets one free game of each a day. This button opens a fair board against three bots that race you for the bonus cards.

Play this board free

CATAN is a registered trademark of Catan GmbH. Hearthsea is an independent game and is not affiliated with, endorsed by or sponsored by Catan GmbH or its publishers. Other game names belong to their owners and are used here only to describe and compare.