Hearthsea

Catan ports and harbors: the rules, and is a 2:1 worth it?

A Catan port (called a harbor before the 6th edition) lets a player with a settlement or city on it trade with the bank at a better rate: 3 of any one resource for 1 at a 3:1 port, or 2 of the resource shown for 1 at a 2:1 port. There are 9: four 3:1 and one 2:1 for each resource. In 10,000 simulated games, players who started on a port won 26.6% of the time against 24.6% for those who didn’t.

A painting of the coast of a hex island board game: wooden piers with small sailing ships, round harbour tokens reading 2:1 and 3:1, a settlement on a harbour corner and stacks of coins and resource cards on the table.
Two corners of coast, a pier, and a better rate at the bank.

How ports work in Catan

A port changes one number: how many cards the bank wants from you.

Without a port you can always trade with the bank at 4:1, four of one resource for one of any other. A port lowers that rate for the player who owns it. Each port touches two corners of the coast; a settlement or city on either corner gives you the port.

The three bank rates in Catan
RateWho gets itWhat you give
4:1Everyone, always4 of any one resource
3:1A building on a 3:1 port (the “?” port in older editions)3 of any one resource
2:1A building on that resource’s 2:1 port2 of the resource shown on the port

Port rules people argue about

  • Can you start on a port? Yes. Your starting settlements can go on port corners like any other legal corner, and you can use the port from your first turn.
  • Does the robber block a port? No. The official FAQ is clear: the robber stops a land hex from producing, and a port keeps working even when the robber sits on the hex beside it.
  • Only your own ports. You can’t use a port where another player has the building.
  • Only on your turn. Bank trades, at any rate, happen during your own turn.
  • As often as you like. There is no limit on port trades per turn, as long as you have the cards.
  • A 2:1 port only takes its own resource. A 2:1 wool port turns 2 wool into anything; it does nothing for your ore. For other resources, you still trade at 4:1, or 3:1 if you also own a 3:1 port.
  • A city doesn’t improve the rate. A settlement and a city on a port give the same trade.

Is a port worth it? What 10,000 games say

We had Hearthsea’s strongest bots play 10,000 four-player games on freshly dealt boards and recorded which ports each player started on. A fair share of wins is 25%.

Win rate by the port a player started on

  • No port24.6%
  • 3:1 port28.2%
  • 2:1 port26.0%

Fair share: 25%

Win rate by starting port, 10,000 four-player games of Hearthsea’s Veteran bots. Port starts averaged 18.8 pips against 20.1 without, and still won more.

Three things stand out:

  • Ports pay for their weak numbers. Port corners are usually poorer, 18.8 pips on average against 20.1, yet port starts won 26.6% of games against 24.6%.
  • The plain 3:1 did best. 28.2%, against 26.0% for a 2:1. A 3:1 turns any surplus into what you need; a 2:1 needs a steady supply of one resource.
  • Matching the 2:1 to your best resource mattered little. 26.2% when it matched, 25.6% when it didn’t.

Each group has between about 1,900 and 32,000 starting positions, so differences under 2 points are within the noise. These are bots, which trade differently from people; treat the numbers as a direction, not a law.

Which 2:1 port is best?

Win rate by the 2:1 port a player started on (10,000 games, about 1,100 players each)
2:1 portWin rate
Wood28.3%
Brick26.3%
Wool25.1%
Grain (wheat)21.9%
Ore28.3%

Ore and wood ports led at 28.3% and 28.3%; the grain port trailed at 21.9%. With about 1,100 players each, only the gap between the best and the grain port is clearly more than noise.

Port strategy that works

  • Pair a 2:1 with a strong hex of the same resource. A 2:1 wheat port next to a wheat field on 6 or 8 turns every roll of that number into a free choice of card.
  • Take a 3:1 when your numbers are lopsided. If your start is heavy in one or two resources, a 3:1 is your trade partner who never says no.
  • Plan your second or third settlement for the port. You don’t need it at the start. A road toward the coast in the first few turns often reaches one.
  • Ports matter more with three players. With fewer people to trade with, the bank is busier. See our 3-player guide.

Play a board with all nine ports
A free account opens this fair board against three bots.

Questions people ask

How do ports work in Catan?

If you have a settlement or city on a port’s corner, you can trade with the bank at its rate on your turn: 3 of any one resource for 1 at a 3:1 port, or 2 of the shown resource for 1 at a 2:1 port.

Can you start on a port in Catan?

Yes. A starting settlement can go on a port corner, and you can use the port from your first turn.

Does the robber block a port in Catan?

No. The robber only stops a land hex from producing. Ports keep working.

What does the question mark port mean in Catan?

It is a 3:1 port: trade 3 of any one resource for 1 of another. Older editions printed a question mark on it.

How many ports are in Catan?

Nine in the base game: four 3:1 ports and five 2:1 ports, one for each resource. The 5–6 player extension adds two more. In the 6th edition they are printed on the sea frame.

Is a 2:1 port better than a 3:1?

Not by default. In our 10,000 simulated games, 3:1 starts won 28.2% and 2:1 starts 26.0%. A 2:1 is strong when you produce a lot of its resource.

Sources

Read on 15 November 2026:

  1. CATAN – The Game: 6th edition rulebook (PDF)
  2. CATAN: base game rules and almanac, 5th edition (PDF)
  3. CATAN: base game FAQ
  4. Hearthsea: we simulated 10,000 games of Catan (method and data)

Keep reading

Put a settlement on a port

Hearthsea is free to play: Classic and Seafarers on every island, against bots or online with friends, with no daily limit. Highlands, Skyfarers, The Spice Road and Cities & Knights cost $4.99 a month each, or $9.99 a month for all four, and every account gets one free game of each a day. The button opens a fair four-player board with all nine ports, against three bots.

Play this board free

CATAN is a registered trademark of Catan GmbH. Hearthsea is an independent game and is not affiliated with, endorsed by or sponsored by Catan GmbH or its publishers. Other game names belong to their owners and are used here only to describe and compare.