Hearthsea

Is Catan luck or skill? We ran 26,000 games to find out

Catan is a skill game with a lot of luck in any single game. In 10,000 simulated four-player games, Hearthsea’s strongest bot beat three beginner bots 80.8% of the time, so the dice still beat it about 1 game in 5. Against three solid bots it won 51.6%, about twice a fair share of 25%, and lost the rest.

A painting of two dice frozen in mid-air above a hex island board game while a player rests his chin on his hand, pencil and notebook ready, half the scene in warm light and half in shadow.
Two dice in the air, and the player who planned for either result.

The short answer

Here is the uncomfortable part first: the strongest player at the table loses most Catan games.

That sounds like luck wins. It doesn’t. With four players a fair share is 1 win in 4. A clearly better player wins more than that, often about twice as much, but the other three still share the rest. One night of Catan says little about who is better. Twenty nights say a lot.

How we tested it

Hearthsea has three bot levels that differ only in how they play, never in their dice: the Settler (a beginner: rough placement, hoards cards), the Merchant (a solid player) and the Veteran (our strongest: plans ahead, reads the leader, trades hard). All three roll the same fair dice, and none sees the others’ cards.

We seated one Veteran with three weaker bots, rotated its seat every game so turn order evened out, and dealt a fresh board each time:

  • 10,000 four-player games: one Veteran against three Settlers
  • 10,000 four-player games: one Veteran against three Merchants
  • 6,000 three-player games: one Veteran against two Merchants

How often skill beats the dice

How often the strongest bot won

  • vs 3 beginners80.8%
  • vs 3 solid players51.6%
  • vs 2 solid (3 players)58.6%
Win rate of Hearthsea’s Veteran bot, 26,000 simulated games. A fair share is 25% with four players and 33% with three.
  • Against beginners, skill dominates, but not completely. 80.8% wins. One game in five still went to a Settler.
  • Against good players, the edge is real but modest. 51.6% is double a fair share, and it still means losing nearly every other game.
  • Fewer players, more control. With three at the table the Veteran won 58.6%: one fewer rival to get lucky.

When the Veteran lost, it finished on 6.98 points on average against solid bots: close, but behind. Across all the games against solid bots, 26.1% ended with the winner only 1 point ahead of the next player.

Why you can lose five games in a row and still be good

A player who wins 52% of games against good opponents still goes five games without a win 2.7% of the time, about 1 stretch in 38. A player at a fair 25% goes five without a win 24% of the time. Losing streaks are normal, and they say little about skill until they get long.

What top players say

Champions put the split in similar places:

  • Treeckosaurus, two-time Catan champion: “I think the game is 70% skill and 30% luck.”
  • Elliott Yap, 2023 Australian champion: in about 30% of games “you will always lose due to luck or board dynamic,” in 10% you win from luck, and in the other 60% “there is always something you can do to improve your chances.”
  • Win rates at the top: Rayman, widely rated among the best players in the world, won 39% of 200 four-player games in late 2021, and DandyDrew 41% of 139, as Felipe Maranha recorded. That is about 1.6 times a fair share of 25%.

Where the luck in Catan comes from

  • The dice. In our dice study of 14,285 games of 70 rolls, the number of 7s in a game ranged from 1 to 26. Our balanced dice study shows how a 36-card deck of rolls narrows that.
  • The board. A random deal can leave one seat with a far better first pick. A fair board generator fixes most of it.
  • Turn order. The first player wins a little more often, about 3 points above a fair share with four players.
  • The robber and steals. Who gets robbed, and which card is taken, is a coin flip.

Where the skill is

  • Starting placement. Pips, variety and room to grow. See Catan numbers and odds.
  • Trading. Getting what you need without handing the leader what they need.
  • Reading the table. Knowing who is close to 10 and when to stop trading with them.
  • Spreading risk. Several numbers, a port, a hand kept at 7 cards or fewer when a 7 is due.

Test your skill on a tournament-tight board
A board dealt with the strictest fairness rules, so the result is more you and less the deal. A free account opens it.

Questions people ask

Is Catan more luck or skill?

Both. A better player wins clearly more often over many games, but any single game has a lot of luck. Our strongest bot won 51.6% of four-player games against good bots and 80.8% against beginners.

Can a good player lose at Catan to beginners?

Yes, regularly. In our simulations the strongest bot still lost about 1 game in 5 to three beginner bots.

Why do I always lose at Catan?

Often it is the table, not you: with four players even a strong player loses most games. If you lose far more than 3 in 4 over 20 games, look at starting placement and trading first.

How can I reduce luck in Catan?

Use a fair board, play with balanced dice or a dice deck, and play more games. Variance evens out over many games.

Is Catan a game of chance?

Not only. It uses dice, but placement, trading and timing decide most games over time.

Sources

Read on 15 November 2026:

  1. Colonist blog: Catan strategies with Treeckosaurus
  2. Player2: interview with Catan national champion Elliott Yap
  3. Felipe Maranha: Breaking the binary mindset (win rates of top players)
  4. Hearthsea: we simulated 10,000 games of Catan (method and data)
  5. Hearthsea: balanced dice vs real dice (14,285 simulated games)
  6. CATAN – The Game: 6th edition rulebook (PDF)

Keep reading

Play the Veteran yourself

Hearthsea is free to play: Classic and Seafarers on every island, against bots or online with friends, with no daily limit. Highlands, Skyfarers, The Spice Road and Cities & Knights cost $4.99 a month each, or $9.99 a month for all four, and every account gets one free game of each a day. The button opens a tournament-tight board against three bots; pick Veteran bots and see how often you win.

Take on the bots free

CATAN is a registered trademark of Catan GmbH. Hearthsea is an independent game and is not affiliated with, endorsed by or sponsored by Catan GmbH or its publishers. Other game names belong to their owners and are used here only to describe and compare.